How to Choose Stock Photos That Don’t Look Cheesy

Master the art of selecting authentic stock photos that captivate audiences instead of making them cringe with these proven techniques.

You’ll spot cheesy stock photos by their fake smiles, awkward handshakes, and overly perfect scenarios that scream “hired models.” Choose authentic images by checking technical quality—sharp focus, natural lighting, and accurate colours. Use reverse image searches to avoid overused photos that’ll make your brand look generic. Look for natural compositions with real emotions and diverse representation that matches your audience. Proper post-processing should improve, not create plastic-looking perfection that destroys authenticity and trust with your customers.

Technical Quality Standards That Make Photos Look Professional

Second, evaluate sharpness and focus. The main subject should be crisp without over-sharpening halos around edges.

Accidental blur kills professionalism instantly.

Third, assess lighting quality. Professional images maintain even illumination with balanced shadow detail.

Harsh shadows or blown-out highlights indicate rushed photography.

Finally, examine colour accuracy. Proper white balance prevents unnatural colour casts, while consistent skin tones signal careful post-processing work. Many stock photo platforms now offer API access to help developers integrate quality image selection into their workflows seamlessly.

Aligning Images With Your Brand Context and Purpose

Your colour palette must align across every image. If your brand uses muted tones, don’t suddenly throw in bright primary colours that clash.

Images should tell the same visual story, even when exact brand colours aren’t present. Colour association can be more impactful than logos alone when establishing brand recognition. Maintaining visual consistency across all media strengthens how stakeholders perceive your business and builds trust.

Consider your audience demographics carefully. Using models that reflect your target market’s cultural backgrounds creates stronger connections.

Authentic representation in your visuals builds trust and resonates deeply with audiences who see themselves reflected in your brand.

Remember, 16% of the world’s population lives with disabilities—inclusive representation matters.

This is especially important to younger audiences aged 18-25 who scrutinise brand values closely.

Identifying and Avoiding Overused Stock Photography

How often have you noticed that same smiling businessman in a suit appearing on numerous different company websites? That’s the clear indicator of overused stock photography, and it’s damaging your brand’s authenticity.

Before buying any image, run it through TinEye’s reverse search tool. If you see “121 results” or a similarly high number, you’ve stumbled upon an overused photo that’ll make your business appear generic. Google’s drag-and-drop search can pick up additional instances that TinEye might overlook.

Steer clear of the worst culprits: cheesy handshakes between anonymous businesspeople, over-the-top team celebrations, and those grinning customer service representatives with headsets. These types scream “stock photo” to South African consumers who value authenticity. Research indicates that real customer images consistently outperform stock photography in marketing tests and result in higher engagement rates.

Rights Managed licences provide exclusive use within your market. This stops your competitors from using the same imagery across Johannesburg, Cape Town, or Durban.

Composition Techniques for Authentic Visual Appeal

Anyone can spot a poorly composed stock photo from a mile away—the awkward poses, random white space, and subjects staring blankly into the distance give it away instantly.

Bad stock photos scream amateur with their stiff poses, awkward spacing, and lifeless subjects gazing into nothingness.

You’ll want images that use natural leading lines like staircases, pathways, or structural elements to guide viewers’ eyes purposefully through the frame.

Look for photos with layered depth—foreground, middle ground, and background elements that create dimensional interest. The best shots position main subjects in the middle layer with no more than 25% foreground coverage.

Seek lively viewpoints that break away from standard eye-level perspectives.

Photos taken from low angles or raised positions create more engaging compositions than predictable standing-height shots.

Natural framing elements like doorways or windows add authenticity while drawing attention to your subject matter.

Post-Production Tips to Enhance Rather Than Overprocess

While composition gets your stock photo noticed, smart post-production work determines whether it looks professional or screams “amateur hour.”

The goal isn’t to alter your image into something unrecognisable—it’s to polish what’s already there.

Focus on these essential post-production techniques:

  • Colour correction and exposure balance – Remove colour casts and adjust lighting whilst maintaining natural appearance
  • Gentle noise reduction – Clean up grainy artefacts from high ISO settings. Avoid creating plastic-looking skin textures.
  • Lens distortion correction – Apply manufacturer profiles to fix barrel distortion and viewpoint issues automatically
  • Subtle sharpening – Improve detail clarity without creating artificial halos around edges. Keep the enhancement natural and believable.
  • Minimal background refinement – Use precise masking only when necessary for complex silhouettes

Remember: skilful post-production improves authenticity rather than destroying it.

Table of Contents

Recent Blog

Let’s build your website now

Ready to turn ideas into a fast, search-friendly WordPress site? I’ll map a simple plan with clear milestones and a launch date—then handle design, build, and performance tuning.